Planning a baby shower is exciting—until you realize you also need prizes for the games. Suddenly you’re asking yourself questions like: What won’t end up in the trash? What feels thoughtful but not expensive? What will guests actually be excited to win?
Good news: baby shower game prizes don’t have to be cheesy, boring, or overpriced. With the right ideas, your prizes can feel fun, stylish, and genuinely useful—while staying totally budget-friendly.
Whether you’re hosting a cozy brunch shower, a big backyard celebration, or a modern co-ed baby shower, this guide breaks down the best baby shower game prize ideas by category, personality, and price point so you can easily mix and match.
This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate and affiliate partner, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. These commissions help support this site and allow me to continue creating helpful content. Thank you for your support!
Why Baby Shower Game Prizes Matter More Than You Think
Baby shower games are meant to break the ice and create laughter—but prizes are the icing on the cake. Thoughtful prizes:
- Encourage participation (especially from shy guests)
- Make games feel more intentional and fun
- Leave guests with a positive takeaway from your event
- Elevate the overall feel of the shower
The key is choosing prizes that feel useful, indulgent, or entertaining—not like an afterthought.
Best Baby Shower Game Prize Ideas (That Guests Love)
🎁 1. Candles (A Crowd Favorite for a Reason)
Candles are one of the safest, most universally loved baby shower game prizes. They feel cozy, giftable, and a little luxurious—especially when you choose neutral or seasonal scents.
Why candles work:
- Great for all ages and genders
- Easy to find in bulk
- Feel more expensive than they are
Pro tip: Look for soy candles, minimalist jars, or soft scents like vanilla, eucalyptus, or linen.
🍫 2. Gourmet Treats & Sweet Indulgences
Edible prizes are always a win—because no one feels guilty taking them home. Think beyond basic candy and lean into elevated treats.
Popular edible prize ideas:
- Artisan chocolates or truffles
- Gourmet popcorn or snack tins
- Honey jars or specialty jams
- Cookies or brownie gift boxes
These work especially well for brunch or afternoon showers.
🛁 3. Self-Care & Pampering Prizes
Self-care prizes are perfect for baby showers because they subtly remind guests to take care of themselves too—especially moms attending.
Easy self-care prize ideas:
- Bath bombs or shower steamers
- Hand creams or body lotions
- Face masks or eye patches
- Mini spa kits
These prizes feel indulgent without being overly personal.
☕ 4. Coffee & Tea Lover Gifts
You’ll never go wrong with caffeine-themed prizes. Coffee and tea items are practical, comforting, and universally appreciated.
Great options include:
- Coffee mugs with neutral sayings
- Gourmet coffee samplers
- Loose-leaf tea sets
- Insulated tumblers
These prizes are especially popular for fall or winter baby showers.
🕯️ 5. Mini Home Décor Finds
Small décor pieces make wonderful baby shower game prizes—especially for guests who love cozy spaces.
Home-inspired prize ideas:
- Decorative coasters
- Trinket trays
- Mini picture frames
- Seasonal décor accents
Stick to neutral tones so they fit easily into most homes.
🌿 6. Plants & Green Gifts
Plants symbolize growth—making them especially meaningful for a baby shower.
Plant prize ideas:
- Succulents
- Herb starter kits
- Small potted plants
- Seed packets with planters
These are perfect for spring and summer showers.
💄 7. Beauty & Lifestyle Favorites
Beauty items work best when you keep them neutral and universally appealing.
Safe beauty prize ideas:
- Lip balms or glosses
- Nail care kits
- Makeup remover cloths
- Compact mirrors
Avoid heavily scented or skin-specific items unless you know your audience well.
🎉 8. Fun & Funny Prize Options
If your shower includes silly games or competitive guests, playful prizes are a hit.
Lighthearted prize ideas:
- Socks with funny sayings
- Trivia books or puzzles
- Mini games or card decks
- Wine stoppers or bottle openers
These work especially well for co-ed or couples’ baby showers.
Budget-Friendly Baby Shower Game Prize Ideas
You don’t need to spend a fortune to create great prizes. Many of the best baby shower game prize ideas cost under $10 when bought in multipacks.
Money-saving tips:
- Buy sets and split them into individual prizes
- Choose items that look elevated (packaging matters!)
- Mix “big” and “small” prizes so not every winner gets the same thing
How Many Baby Shower Game Prizes Do You Need?
A good rule of thumb:
- 1 prize per game winner
- 1–2 “bonus” prizes (for ties or surprise wins)
- Optional grand prize for competitive games
Most baby showers need 5–10 prizes total, depending on the number of games.
How to Present Baby Shower Game Prizes (Don’t Skip This!)
Presentation can make even a simple prize feel special.
Easy presentation ideas:
- Wrap items in clear gift bags with ribbon
- Display prizes on a dedicated table
- Add small tags like “You Won!” or “Game Champion”
- Group prizes by theme
A visually appealing prize table also doubles as décor.
Final Thoughts: Choosing the Best Baby Shower Game Prize Ideas
The best baby shower game prize ideas are thoughtful, useful, and easy to love. When in doubt, choose something cozy, consumable, or practical—and don’t overthink it.
Your guests are there to celebrate the baby and enjoy the moment. A great prize simply makes the experience even sweeter.
